1812 United States presidential election

1812 United States presidential election
217 members of the Electoral College; 109 electoral votes needed to win
Turnout	40.4% 3.6 pp
	Presidential election results map. Green denotes states won by Madison and Light Orange denotes states won by Clinton. Numbers indicate the number of electoral votes cast by each state.
President before election; James Madison; Democratic-Republican	Elected President ; James Madison; Democratic-Republican

Presidential elections were held in the United States from October 30 to December 2, 1812. In the shadow of the War of 1812, incumbent Democratic-Republican President James Madison defeated DeWitt Clinton, the lieutenant governor of New York and mayor of New York City, who drew support from dissident Democratic-Republicans in the North as well as Federalists. It was the first presidential election to be held during a major war involving the United States.^[2]

Northern Democratic-Republicans had long been dissatisfied by the Southern dominance of their party, and DeWitt Clinton's uncle, Vice President George Clinton, had unsuccessfully challenged Madison for the party's 1808 presidential nomination. While the May 1812 Democratic-Republican congressional nominating caucus re-nominated Madison, the party's New York caucus, also held in May, nominated Clinton for president. After the United States declared war on the United Kingdom in June 1812, Clinton sought to create a coalition of anti-war Democratic-Republicans and Federalists.^[3] With Clinton in the race, the Federalist Party declined to formally put forth a nominee, hoping its members would vote for Clinton, but they did not formally endorse him, fearing that an explicit endorsement of Clinton would hurt the party's fortunes in other races. Federalist Jared Ingersoll of Pennsylvania became Clinton's de facto running mate. A dissident faction of the Federalist Party attempted to nominate former vice presidential candidate Rufus King over Clinton, but only succeeded in doing so in Virginia.

Despite Clinton's success at attracting Federalist support, Madison was re-elected with 50.4 percent of the popular vote to his opponent's 47.6%, making the 1812 election the closest election up to that point in the popular vote (there was no popular vote in half the states). Clinton won the Federalist bastion of New England as well as three Mid-Atlantic states, but Madison dominated the South and took Pennsylvania. This was the narrowest popular vote margin for a victorious re-elected president until 2004.

Background

Residual military conflict resulting from the Napoleonic Wars in Europe had been steadily worsening throughout James Madison's first term, with the British Empire and the French Empire both ignoring the neutrality rights of the United States at sea by seizing American ships and looking for supposed British deserters in a practice known as impressment. The British provided additional provocations by impressing American seamen, maintaining forts within United States territory in the Northwest, and supporting American Indians at war with the United States in both the Northwest and Southwest.

Meanwhile, expansionists in the south and west of the United States coveted British Canada and Spanish Florida and wanted to use British provocations as a pretext to seize both areas. The pressure steadily built, with the result that the United States declared war on the United Kingdom on June 12, 1812. This occurred after Madison had been nominated by the Democratic-Republicans, but before the Federalists had made their nomination. He won the nomination with 128 votes.

Nominations

Democratic-Republican Party nomination

James Madison	Elbridge Gerry
Democratic-Republican Party 1812 Democratic-Republican Party Ticket
for President	for Vice President

4th President of the United States (1809–1817)	9th Governor of Massachusetts (1810–1812)

Democratic-Republican candidates:

President
James Madison
Mayor and Lt. Governor
DeWitt Clinton
of New York
Vice President
George Clinton
(Died April 20)

Many Democratic-Republicans in the northern states were unhappy over the perceived dominance of the presidency by the state of Virginia (three of the last four presidents had been Virginians), and they wished instead to nominate one of their own rather than re-nominate President Madison. Initially, these hopes were pinned upon Vice President George Clinton, but his poor health and advanced age (72) eliminated his chances. Even before Clinton's death on April 20, 1812, his nephew New York Lieutenant Governor DeWitt Clinton was considered the preferred candidate to move against Madison by the northern Democratic-Republicans.

Hoping to forestall a serious movement against President James Madison and a division of the Democratic-Republican Party, some proposed making DeWitt Clinton the nominee for the vice presidency, taking over the same office his uncle now held. DeWitt Clinton was not opposed to the offer, but preferred to wait until after the conclusion of the New York caucus, which would not be held until after the congressional caucus had met, to finalize his decision. Early caucuses were held in the states of Virginia and Pennsylvania, both of which pledged their support to Madison.

Eighty-three of the one hundred thirty-eight of the Democratic-Republican members of the United States Congress attended the nominating caucus in May 1812. The delegations from New York and New England had less representation due to the New York members supporting DeWitt Clinton's attempt to gain the support of the Federalists and the New England members opposing Madison's foreign policy. Eighty-two of the delegates voted to give the presidential nomination to Madison while John Langdon won the vice-presidential nomination against Elbridge Gerry by a vote of sixty-four to sixteen. However, Langdon declined the nomination citing his age and it was instead given to Gerry after another vote was held with seventy-four delegates voting for him.^[4]

When the New York caucus did meet on May 29, it was dominated by anti-war Democratic-Republicans, and nominated DeWitt Clinton for the presidency almost unanimously.^[3] Clinton's now open candidacy was opposed by many who, while not friends of James Madison, feared that Clinton was now apt to tear the Democratic-Republican party asunder. The matter of how to conduct his campaign also became a major problem for Clinton, especially with regards to the war with the British after June 12. Many of Clinton's supporters were war-hawks who advocated extreme measures to force the British into negotiations favorable to the United States, while Clinton knew he would have to appeal to Federalists to win, and they were almost wholly opposed to the war.^[5]

First Caucus Balloting
Presidential Ballot		Vice Presidential Ballot
James Madison	81	John Langdon	64
Abstaining	1	Elbridge Gerry	16
		Scattering	2

Second Caucus Balloting
Vice Presidential Ballot
Elbridge Gerry	74
Scattering	3

Federalist nomination

DeWitt Clinton	Jared Ingersoll
Federalist Party 1812 Federalist Party Ticket
for President	for Vice President

5th Lieutenant Governor of New York (1811–1813) 47th, 49th and 51st Mayor of New York City (1803–1807, 1808–1810, & 1811–1815)	5th & 11th Attorney General of Pennsylvania (1791–1800 & 1811–1816)

Federalist candidates:

Mayor and Lt. Governor
DeWitt Clinton
of New York
Chief Justice of the United States
John Marshall
(Declined to Contest)

Before Clinton entered the race as an alternative to President Madison, Chief Justice John Marshall was a favorite for the Federalist presidential nomination, a relatively popular figure who could carry much of the Northeast while potentially taking Virginia and North Carolina as well. But with Clinton in the race, the Federalists would no longer be able to count on the electoral votes of New York, possibly throwing the election into the House of Representatives, dominated by Democratic-Republicans, where Madison would almost certainly be elected.

In the face of these facts, the Federalist party considered endorsing Clinton's candidacy for a time, but at their caucus in September it was decided that the party simply would not field a presidential candidate that year and did not endorse Clinton. Though there was much support among the Federalists for Clinton, it was felt that openly endorsing him as the party's choice for president would damage his chances in states where the Federalists remained unpopular and drive away Democratic-Republicans who would normally be supportive of his candidacy. A Federalist caucus in Pennsylvania chose to nominate Jared Ingersoll, the Attorney General of the state, as Clinton's vice presidential running-mate, a move Clinton decided to support considering the importance of Pennsylvania's electors.^[5]

Straight-Federalist nomination

Rufus King	William R. Davie
Federalist Party 1812 Straight-Federalist Party Ticket
for President	for Vice President

3rd U.S. Minister to Great Britain (1796–1803)	10th Governor of North Carolina (1798–1799)

While many Federalists were supportive of DeWitt Clinton's candidacy, others were not so keen, skeptical of Clinton's positions regarding the war and other matters. Rufus King, a former diplomat and Representative, had led an effort at the September Caucus to nominate a Federalist ticket for the election that year, though he was ultimately unsuccessful. Still, some wished to enter King's name into the race under the Federalist label, and while very little came of it, it caused problems for the Clinton campaign in two states.

In the case of Virginia, Clinton was rejected entirely by the state Federalist Party, which instead chose to nominate Rufus King for president and William Richardson Davie for vice president. The ticket would acquire about 27% of the vote in the state. In New York, with the Federalists having gained control of the state legislature that summer, it was planned that the Federalists would nominate a slate pledged to Rufus King now that they had the majority. However, a coalition of Democratic-Republicans and Federalists would defeat the motion and succeed in nominating a slate pledged to Clinton.^[5]

General election

Campaign

The war heavily overshadowed the campaign.^[2] Clinton continued his regional campaigning, adopting an anti-war stance in the Northeast (which was most harmed by the war), and a pro-war stance in the South and West. The election ultimately hinged on New York and Pennsylvania, and while Clinton took his home state, he failed to take Pennsylvania and thus lost the election.^[2] Though Clinton lost, the election was the best showing for the Federalists since that of Adams, as the party made gains in Congress and kept the presidential election reasonably close. Clintonite Democratic-Republicans in many states refused to work with their Federalist counterparts (notably in Pennsylvania) and Clinton was generally regarded by most as the Federalist candidate, though he was not formally nominated by them.^[5]

Results

Madison was the first of just four presidents in United States history to win re-election with a lower percentage of the electoral vote than in their prior elections, as Madison won 69.3% of the electoral vote in 1808, but only won 58.7% of the electoral vote in 1812. The other three were Woodrow Wilson in 1916, Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1940 and 1944 and Barack Obama in 2012. Additionally, Madison was the first of only five presidents to win re-election with a smaller percentage of the popular vote than in prior elections, although in 1812, only 6 of the 18 states chose electors by popular vote. The other four are Andrew Jackson in 1832, Grover Cleveland in 1892, Franklin Roosevelt in 1940 and 1944, and Barack Obama in 2012.

This was the closest re-election for an incumbent president until the 2004 election.

Electoral results
Presidential candidate	Party	Home state	Popular vote^{(a), (b)}		Electoral vote^(c)	Running mate
Presidential candidate	Party	Home state	Count	Percentage	Electoral vote^(c)	Vice-presidential candidate	Home state	Electoral vote^(c)
James Madison (incumbent)	Democratic-Republican	Virginia	140,431	50.4%	128	Elbridge Gerry	Massachusetts	128
DeWitt Clinton	Democratic-Republican	New York	132,781	47.6%	89	Jared Ingersoll	Pennsylvania	86
DeWitt Clinton	Democratic-Republican	New York	132,781	47.6%	89	Elbridge Gerry	Massachusetts	3
Rufus King	Federalist	New York	5,583	2.1%	0	William R. Davie	North Carolina	0
Unpledged electors	None	N/A	661	0.2%	0	N/A	N/A	0
Total			279,456	100%	217			217
Needed to win					109			109

Source (Popular Vote): United States Presidential Elections, 1788-1860: The Official Results by Michael J. Dubin^[6]
Source (Popular Vote): A New Nation Votes: American Election Returns 1787–1825^[7]
Source (Electoral Vote): "Electoral College Box Scores 1789–1996". National Archives and Records Administration. Retrieved July 30, 2005.

^(a) Only 9 of the 18 states chose electors by popular vote.
^(b) Those states that did choose electors by popular vote had widely varying restrictions on suffrage via property requirements.
^(c) One elector from Ohio did not vote.

Popular vote

Madison			50.4%
Clinton			47.6%
King			2.1%
Unpledged electors			0.2%

Electoral vote—President

Madison			59%
Clinton			41%

Electoral vote—Vice President

Gerry			60.4%
Ingersoll			39.6%

Maps

Electoral College map
Map of presidential election results by county, shaded according to the vote share of the highest result for an elector of any given candidate
Map of presidential election results by electoral district, shaded according to the vote share of the highest result for an elector of any given candidate. Electoral boundaries for Maryland and most of Tennessee could not be found

Popular vote by state

Elections in this period were vastly different from modern day presidential elections. The actual presidential candidates were rarely mentioned on tickets and voters were voting for particular electors who were pledged to a particular candidate. There was sometimes confusion as to who the particular elector was actually pledged to. Results are reported as the highest result for an elector for any given candidate. For example, if three Madison electors received 100, 50, and 25 votes, Madison would be recorded as having 100 votes. Confusion surrounding the way results are reported may lead to discrepancies between the sum of all state results and national results.

Returns below are from A New Nation Votes. The vote totals of Kentucky appear to be incomplete, and those of Tennessee appear to be lost.^[8]


State (Electoral votes for Madison & Clinton)	James Madison Democratic-Republican		DeWitt Clinton Democratic-Republican		Rufus King Federalist		Other		Margin for Madison
	#	%	#	%	#	%	#	%	#	%
Kentucky (12-0)	8,501+	92.17%	433+	4.69%	No ballots		289	3.13%	7,779	84.35%
Maryland (6-5)	13,970+	51.62%	13,091+	48.37%	No ballots		4	0.01%	875	3.24%
Massachusetts (0-22)	27,314	35.03%	50,639	64.95%	No ballots		13+	0.02%	-23,338	-29.94%
New Hampshire (0-8)	15,907	43.89%	20,286	55.97%	No ballots		49	0.14%	-4,428	-12.22%
Ohio (7-0)	7,420	69.2%	3,301	30.8%	No ballots		No ballots		4,119	38.4%
Pennsylvania (25-0)	best performing elector was run on both the Madison and Clinton tickets^[a]				No ballots		3	<0.01%	79,125	>99.99%
Rhode Island (0-4)	2,084	34.07%	4,032	65.93%	No ballots		No ballots		-1,948	-31.86%
Tennessee (8-0)	No data	100%	No ballots		No ballots		No ballots		No data	100%
Virginia (25-0)	15,128	71.99%	No ballots		5,583	26.57%	303	1.44%	9,241	43.98%

States that flipped from Democratic-Republican to Federalist

States where the margin of victory was under 5%

Maryland, 3.24% (875 votes)

Electoral college selection

Method of choosing electors	State(s)
Each elector appointed by state legislature	Connecticut Delaware Georgia Louisiana New Jersey New York North Carolina South Carolina Vermont
Each elector chosen by voters statewide	New Hampshire Ohio Pennsylvania Rhode Island Virginia
State is divided into three electoral districts, with four electors chosen per district by the voters of each district	Kentucky
State is divided into electoral districts, with one elector chosen per district by the voters of that district	Maryland Tennessee
Two electors chosen by voters statewide One elector chosen per congressional district by the voters of that district	Massachusetts

In New Jersey, Federalists had just taken over the state legislature and decided to change the method of choosing electors from a general election to appointment by state legislature. Some towns, possibly too far away to get the news, or in open defiance of the switch, held elections anyway. These were not counted nor reported by the newspapers. In the unofficial elections, Madison received 1,672 votes while Clinton only received 2, suggesting these were protest votes (New Jersey was far more competitive than this at the time).^[10]

Notes

^ The best performing elector in Pennsylvania, David Meade, was run on both the Madison and Clinton tickets. He received 79,128 votes, more than any other elector in the state.^[9] As to not represent Pennsylvania voters twice in popular vote figures, the votes have been split proportionally to the rest of the slates (62.64%-37.36%)

^ John Langdon had originally been nominated as Madison's running mate; however, Langdon declined the nomination and Gerry was chosen instead.
^ While commonly labeled as the Federalist candidate, Clinton technically ran as a Democratic-Republican and was not nominated by the Federalist party itself, the latter simply deciding not to field a candidate. This did not prevent endorsements from state Federalist parties (such as in Pennsylvania), but he received the endorsement from the New York state Democratic-Republicans as well.

References

^ "National General Election VEP Turnout Rates, 1789-Present". United States Election Project. CQ Press.
^ ^a ^b ^c Sabato, Larry; Ernst, Howard (January 1, 2009). Encyclopedia of American Political Parties and Elections. Infobase Publishing. pp. 303–304.
^ ^a ^b Morison, Samuel Eliot (1965). The Oxford History of the American People. New York: Oxford. p. 383.
^ National Party Conventions, 1831-1976. Congressional Quarterly. 1979.
^ ^a ^b ^c ^d Schlesinger, Arthur M. Jr. (2002). History of American Presidential Elections, 1789–2001. Vol. 1, 1789–1824. Chelsea House Publishers. pp. 249–272. ISBN 978-0791057131.
^ Dubin, Michael J. (2002). United States Presidential Elections, 1788-1860: The Official Results by County and State. Jefferson: McFarland & Company. p. 19. ISBN 9780786410170.
^ "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu.
^ "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu. Retrieved December 10, 2020.
^ "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu. Retrieved June 9, 2024.
^ "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu. p. See note one. Retrieved October 27, 2018.

Bibliography

Boller, Paul F. Jr. (2004). Presidential Campaigns: From George Washington to George W. Bush. Oxford: Oxford University Press. pp. 26–28. ISBN 978-0-19-516716-0.
Siry, Steven Edwin (1985). "The Sectional Politics of "Practical Republicanism": De Witt Clinton's Presidential Bid, 1810–1812". Journal of the Early Republic. 5 (4): 441–462. doi:10.2307/3123061. JSTOR 3123061.
Zinman, Donald A. (2024). America's First Wartime Election: James Madison, DeWitt Clinton, and the War of 1812. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas. ISBN 9780700637799.
A New Nation Votes: American Election Returns, 1787–1825

External links

Presidential Election of 1812: A Resource Guide from the Library of Congress
"A Historical Analysis of the Electoral College". The Green Papers. Retrieved March 20, 2005.
Election of 1812 in Counting the Votes Archived March 11, 2020, at the Wayback Machine

[pa-12] The best performing elector in Pennsylvania, David Meade, was run on both the Madison and Clinton tickets. He received 79,128 votes, more than any other elector in the state.^[9] As to not represent Pennsylvania voters twice in popular vote figures, the votes have been split proportionally to the rest of the slates (62.64%-37.36%)

[2] John Langdon had originally been nominated as Madison's running mate; however, Langdon declined the nomination and Gerry was chosen instead.

[3] While commonly labeled as the Federalist candidate, Clinton technically ran as a Democratic-Republican and was not nominated by the Federalist party itself, the latter simply deciding not to field a candidate. This did not prevent endorsements from state Federalist parties (such as in Pennsylvania), but he received the endorsement from the New York state Democratic-Republicans as well.

[1] "National General Election VEP Turnout Rates, 1789-Present". United States Election Project. CQ Press.

[sabato1-4] Sabato, Larry; Ernst, Howard (January 1, 2009). Encyclopedia of American Political Parties and Elections. Infobase Publishing. pp. 303–304.

[Morison-5] Morison, Samuel Eliot (1965). The Oxford History of the American People. New York: Oxford. p. 383.

[6] National Party Conventions, 1831-1976. Congressional Quarterly. 1979.

[Schlesinger-7] Schlesinger, Arthur M. Jr. (2002). History of American Presidential Elections, 1789–2001. Vol. 1, 1789–1824. Chelsea House Publishers. pp. 249–272. ISBN 978-0791057131.

[8] Dubin, Michael J. (2002). United States Presidential Elections, 1788-1860: The Official Results by County and State. Jefferson: McFarland & Company. p. 19. ISBN 9780786410170.

[9] "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu.

[10] "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu. Retrieved December 10, 2020.

[11] "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu. Retrieved June 9, 2024.

[13] "A New Nation Votes". elections.lib.tufts.edu. p. See note one. Retrieved October 27, 2018.

[1]

[Note 2]

[Note 1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[a]

[10]

[9]

v t e James Madison
4th President of the United States (1809–1817) 5th U.S. Secretary of State (1801–1809) United States House of Representatives (1789–1797) Congress of the Confederation (1781–1783) Virginia House of Delegates (1776–1779, 1784–1786) Delegate, Fifth Virginia Convention (1776)
"Father of the Constitution"	Co-wrote, 1776 Virginia Constitution 1786 Annapolis Convention 1787 Constitutional Convention Virginia Plan Constitution of the United States Notes of Debates in the Federal Convention of 1787 The Federalist Papers written by Madison No. 10 No. 51 Virginia Ratifying Convention United States Bill of Rights 27th amendment Constitution drafting and ratification timeline Tariff of 1789 Founding Fathers
Presidency	First inauguration Second inauguration Tecumseh's War Battle of Tippecanoe War of 1812 origins Henry letters Burning of Washington The Octagon House Treaty of Ghent Seven Buildings residence results Second Barbary War Era of Good Feelings Second Bank of the United States State of the Union Address (1810 1814 1815 1816) Cabinet Federal judiciary appointments
Other noted accomplisments	Co-founder, American Whig Society Co-author, George Washington's Farewell Address Supervised the Louisiana Purchase Anti-Administration party Residence Act Compromise of 1790 Democratic-Republican Party First Party System republicanism Library of Congress Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions Report of 1800
Other writings	Pacificus-Helvidius Debates The Papers of James Madison Founders Online
Life	Early life and career James Madison and slavery Belle Grove Plantation, birthplace Montpelier
Elections	1789 Virginia's 5th congressional district election 1790 1792 1794 U.S. presidential election, 1808 1812
Legacy and popular culture	Bibliography Memorials James Madison Memorial Building statue James Madison University James Madison College Madison, Wisconsin James Madison Park James Madison Memorial High School Madison Square Madison Square Garden Madison River Mount Madison Madison Street U.S. postage stamps James Madison Memorial Fellowship Foundation James Madison Freedom of Information Award James Madison Award James Madison Institute James Madison Museum USRC James Madison USS Madison USS James Madison Magnificent Doll (1946 film) A More Perfect Union (1989 film) Liberty's Kids (2002 series) Hamilton (musical, film) Washington (2020 miniseries)
Related	Age of Enlightenment American Enlightenment Marbury v. Madison National Gazette Paul Jennings Madisonian model Cognitive Madisonianism American Philosophical Society The American Museum magazine Virginia dynasty
Family	Dolley Madison (wife) John Payne Todd (stepson) James Madison Sr. (father) Eleanor Madison (mother) William Madison (brother) Ambrose Madison (grandfather)
← Thomas Jefferson James Monroe → Category:James Madison

v t e United States presidential elections
Elections by year	1788 1792 1796 1800 1804 1808 1812 1816 1820 1824 1828 1832 1836 1840 1844 1848 1852 1856 1860 1864 1868 1872 1876 1880 1884 1888 1892 1896 1900 1904 1908 1912 1916 1920 1924 1928 1932 1936 1940 1944 1948 1952 1956 1960 1964 1968 1972 1976 1980 1984 1988 1992 1996 2000 2004 2008 2012 2016 2020 2024 2028
Elections by state	Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California Colorado Connecticut Delaware District of Columbia Florida Georgia Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey New Mexico New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming
Primaries and caucuses	Iowa caucuses New Hampshire presidential primary Nevada presidential caucuses South Carolina presidential primary Super Tuesday
Nominating conventions	List of nominating conventions Brokered convention Convention bounce Superdelegate
Electoral College and popular vote	Results summary elections in which the winner lost the popular vote Electoral College margins Electoral College results by state electoral vote changes between elections electoral vote recipients popular votes received popular-vote margins Electoral Count Act Certificate of ascertainment Certificate of vote Contingent election Faithless elector Unpledged elector Voter turnout
Related	Campaign slogans Historical election polling Election Day Major party tickets Major party losers Presidential debates October surprise Red states and blue states Swing state Tipping-point state Election recount (2000) Guam straw poll Vice presidential confirmations: 1973 1974
House elections Senate elections Gubernatorial elections

v t e (1811←) 1812 United States elections (→1813)
U.S. President	1812 United States presidential election
U.S. Senate	Connecticut Louisiana North Carolina Ohio Pennsylvania South Carolina Vermont
U.S. House	Connecticut Delaware Georgia At-large sp Indiana Territory Kentucky Louisiana Maryland Massachusetts 17th sp Missouri Territory New Hampshire New York 6th sp Ohio Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina Vermont
Governors	Connecticut Kentucky Louisiana Massachusetts New Hampshire Ohio Rhode Island Vermont Virginia Jan.
States and territories	Connecticut Delaware Georgia Kentucky Louisiana Maryland Massachusetts Missouri New Hampshire New Jersey New York North Carolina Ohio Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina Vermont Virginia